PRACTICAL EDGE
Find Out What Each Order Makes Before You Pay for the Customer
WHY IT WORKS
Deborah tracks product margin, gross margin, contribution one and contribution two at the stage Willow invests. "I care less about EBITDA because if those are in place, we can manage through operating leverage as we scale."
She is fine with losses early. "I don't expect businesses to be profitable from day one." While you prove product-market fit you are subscale on everything. What worries her is the founder who has not done the math and does not know "I'm operating right now at a true negative contribution margin even before I try to acquire a customer."
She lived the other side of it at eToys. "Every incremental order that we shipped, we lost more money and there was no path to changing that." They took it public, and then March 2000 hit.
Contribution one is what an order brings in after you pay for the product, packaging, fulfillment, shipping, payment fees and returns it caused. Contribution two also takes out the marketing it cost to get the order. When contribution one is negative, more ad spend makes the loss bigger.
THE DATA SUPPORTS IT
In July 2022, SimplicityDX reported that ecommerce merchants lost an average of $29 on each new customer, up from $9 in 2013. Acquisition costs and returns accounted for almost all of the increase. The same research put the average repeat sale at $39 for the merchant, up from $28.
On those averages, the second order is the one that pays for the first. That only works if contribution one is positive on every order, including the repeat. SimplicityDX sells ecommerce software, so read this as one vendor's numbers.
HOW I USE IT
At Freshly we made and shipped everything ourselves. We grew to about $550 million in revenue and about 2,500 employees, 200 of them corporate, and every cost of a box ran through a P&L I could see.
Owning the kitchen gave us a cost curve that a brand on a co-man does not get. On the show I said the good and bad of a co-man is that "you can get some marginal benefit, but it's not the same as manufacturing your own product." If you use one, plan on your margin at scale being only a little better than the margin you have today.
THE CHALLENGE
Take one real order from last month for your best-selling product. Write down every cost that order caused, down to the payment fee and the share of returns. Subtract it from what the customer paid. If the number is negative, pick the one lever you will change first, whether that is price, pack size, the free-shipping threshold or your co-man cost, and run the same order again next month.